UPDATE (9:14, September 4, 2009): ADEM disingenuously responds to report card
When the Mobile Press-Register asked about Alabama’s disappointing grade in the recent Gulf Restoration Network report card, ADEM spokesman Scott Hughes choose to continue ADEM’s policy of bait and switch rather than address the concerns that Alabama’s citizens have about the health of our waters. Claiming that the Alabama Rivers Alliance has not contacted ADEM and then calling a report created by a leading team of scientists, engineers, and environmental-protection specialists over a five-year period a “publicity stunt” is a gross misrepresentation.
ARA, along with concerned citizens from across Alabama, are constantly attempting to work with ADEM to better the protection of our rivers, streams, lakes and bays. Within the last two months alone, ARA has attempted to elicit comments from ADEM numerous times.
In July, ARA submitted a ten page memorandum as part of ADEM’s triennial review of Alabama’s water quality program. Among the host of concerns expressed in this document, ARA specifically stated that “while ADEM has provided excellent lake specific criteria for several reservoirs, Alabama still does not have numerical criteria to protect our rivers and streams from the impacts associated with excessive nutrients and stormwater runoff.” ARA also addressed the use of citizen data in monitoring and water use designations. Then, in August, the ADEM Reform Coalition, of which ARA is a member organization, presented our concerns with enforcement to the Alabama Enviromental Managment Commission, which has direct oversight of ADEM and sets environmental policy for our state. In this meeting, Attorney David Ludder presented overwhelming statistical evidence of ADEM’s reduced enforcement of our water pollution law over the last 4 years. In response to this, ADEM director Trey Glenn, took the same position as Mr Hughes.
The question that the people of Alabama are now asking is “when is enough enough?” ADEM keeps giving the old song and dance line that they are “working on it” and “things are getting better.” When is ADEM going to abandon this failed policy of doing as little as possible while shifting blame onto the citizens of the state who merely want a clean and healthy environment free from dangerous pollution and unhealthy fish?
To date, we are still waiting for a response to our comments and Mr. Ludder’s presentation. In the mean time, we will continue to unhesitatingly voice the concerns of Alabama’s citizens from across the state to ADEM in our efforts to protect our rivers.
GULF STATES FAIL TO MAKE THE GRADE IN WATER POLLUTION POLICIES
Gulf Restoration Network Report Reveals Poor Water Quality Policy Gulfwide
BIRMINGHAM, AL- On September 2, the Gulf Restoration Network released its Clean Up Your Act! report card for Gulf State water quality standards. Florida, Alabama, Mississippi, Louisiana, and Texas have received unsatisfactory grades for their failure to implement the Clean Water Act of 1972. The report grades the Gulf States on issues such as water quality standards, policies to prevent Dead Zone-causing pollution, public health protection, and facilitating public participation in the policy-making process.
The Clean Up Your Act! report card indicates that Alabama, along with the other states along the gulf coast, has neglected its responsibility of maintaining healthy waters in the Gulf region. While no Gulf state has adequately taken all the steps to implement the Clean Water Act. Alabama is even further behind. To date, Alabama has failed to implement criteria aimed at the reduction of nitrogen and phosphorus pollution, and has failed to use the best water quality tests to protect the public from disease-causing organisms. Public involvement in state-level compliance with the Clean Water Act has been kept at a minimum. Additionally, Alabama allowed a federally mandated deadline for public hearings to lapse for six months before meeting to review state water policies, although it could be worse, Texas has not held a review process since 2000.
Alabama received a D+, the average grade of all Gulf states. The report indicates that Alabama Department of Environmental Management has failed to implement policies that set specific criteria for nitrogen and phosphorous pollution. This pollution is responsible for harmful algal blooms that cause the annual Dead Zone in the Gulf of Mexico and create hazards for human health, as well as aquatic wildlife. According to Mitch Reid of the Alabama Rivers Alliance, “We are 10 years behind the curve. The failure of the state to act to limit Nitrogen and Phosphorous is strangling our Rivers, Lakes, and Bays and its turning our Gulf coast into a wasteland. The algal blooms which form when fertilizers and other nutrients runoff into the water has the same effect as putting a plastic bag over your head. It’s really hard to combat the effects of other types of pollution when the animals in the water can’t even breath.
Additionally, much of the nitrogen and phosphorous pollution in Alabama water bodies comes from sewage treatment facilities, and the report cautions that ADEM should limit the nutrient pollution allowed into waterways from such facilities. Reid notes that “This is an easy fix. Our treatment facilities are already under state regulation. and there is no reason for us to be failing in this area. ADEM should take the lead in calling for an immediate adoption of the EPA’s recommended standards and then work to ensure that those standards are enforced.”
You can download the full report card at www.healthygulf.org